The History of Beer in New Jersey

If you spent any part of your young adulthood in northern New Jersey, you probably spent a night or two in the Hoboken bars. Or maybe three. So it will come as no surprise that the first brewery in the state was situated right in the middle of the Mile Square, although it was not yet called Hoboken.

A Dutch settler by the name of Aert Teunissen van Putten set up a brewery amidst a Dutch settlement on the banks of the Hudson in 1641. He lasted two years, not because of either the Hoboken police or New Jersey’s alcohol and beverage regulations, neither of which yet existed. Rather, a raid by a tribe of Lenni Lenape in 1643 wiped out both van Putten and his brewery.

For the next couple of centuries most new world beer was home brewed. By most accounts is was a think murky sort of ale. But it was the preferred beverage of many Americans at the time, not because they were anxious to get hammered, but rather because many Europeans came from places where there was nothing in the beer that equaled the toxicity of the water.

beer steins

Drinking vessels from the 19th century on display at the restored Ballantine House in the Newark Museum.

Fortunately in the 19th century we did not have politicians campaigning on the promise to build a wall to keep out immigrants, because it was the flood of German immigrants into the U.S. that made beer brewing a serious business. They brought knowledge, they brought ingredients, and they brought lager, the type of brew that would eventually become the defining style of American beer.

Beer brewing in New Jersey had a definite German accent. So it isn’t surprising that Newark became the state’s beer capital. By 1865, half of Newark’s population was German. The city was home to 242 brewers in 1880, 204 of them were German born.

Gottfried Krueger came here from Germany in 1853 at the age of 16. By 1858 he founded, with a partner, the company that would become Krueger Brewing.  Joseph Hensler, son of a German brewer, arrived in Newark with his father in 1854 and founded the Joseph Hensler Brewing Company. Both of those breweries lasted for more than a century. In 1873 the three Winter Brothers migrated from Germany to Pittsburgh. They founded M Winter Brothers Brewing in 1893. Six years later they sold that firm and moved to New Jersey where they founded the Orange Brewing Company.

Pabst 1911 ad

1911 ad for Pabst Blue Ribbon from the back cover of Judge Magazine

The heyday of beer brewing in the New Jersey was the early 20th century. At the start of the century there were 51 breweries in the state. Twenty-five of those were in Newark. By 1934 that number had been cut in half. Some of New Jersey’s German brewers split for the Midwest due to the anti-German sentiment generated during World War I. But the big blow was the 18th amendment, Prohibition.

New Jersey was not exactly a Prohibition friendly state. In his book Jersey Brew, author Michael Pellegino notes a federal study that estimated that 40% of all alcohol consumed in the U.S. during Prohibition came through Newark. But for legitimate Jersey breweries the onset of Prohibition in 1920 left them with three options: pack it in; try to keep afloat by producing alternatives like soda or near beer (Is that what they called Bud Light in those days?); or go black market and link up with the gangster distribution network.

Among the breweries that closed in 1920 were the Weidenmayer Brewing Company of Newark, Columbia Brewing and Lembeck and Betz Eagle Brewing, both in Jersey City. Newark Trefz’s Brewing was sold to Krueger in that year.

But some of the largest breweries bounced back strong and in fact made beer brewing history. Krueger was ready to go from day one and when Prohibition ended in 1933 they were selling beer in cups from the brewery doorways. This was so popular it gave rise to New Jersey’s first beer riot since the Lenni Lanape raid on Hoboken. The Newark brewery was to change the nature of beer drinking in America when, in conjunction with American Can, it introduced canned beer in 1934. Beer, which was primarily consumed in public houses, was now accessible and convenient for house consumption. It is also during the 30’s that another Newark brewer, Ballantine, is credited by some with producing the first IPA. The Ballantine offering was wood-aged for a year before being bottled.

Another Jersey beer innovation, noted by Pelligrino in his book, came from the Eastern Brewing Corporation in Hammonton. Nude Beer included on its label a bikini clad woman. It was a scratch off. This one didn’t catch on and was pulled from the market.

At mid-century, while Ballantine and Pabst and Krueger were going strong, another milestone in New Jersey beer history occurred. Anheiser-Busch opened a Budweiser plant in Newark in 1951. Thirty-five years later it would be the only remaining brewery in New Jersey.

Garden State brewers survived anti-immigrant sentiment and wars, the religious Right and prohibition, they even survived the gangsters. What they couldn’t survive is the larger trend in American business of consolidation. In the beer industry, like so many others, large national brewers who dominated the marketing and distribution, gobbled up the local and regional manufacturers.

Krueger was merged into Narragansett in 1961. Falstaff bought out Narragansett in 1965 and closed the Newark plant. Ballantine, at one time the third largest brewer in the country, was also bought by Falstaff in 1965 and their Newark site was shut down as well. Newark’s Joseph Hensler Brewing Company, which dated back to 1855, closed in 1958. The Orange Brewing Company was acquired by Rheingold which closed its doors in 1977. Pabst in Newark shut down in 1985. When they took down the big Pabst bottle, which was actually a water tower, from the roof of the old brewery in Newark, it symbolized the end of an era. The big brown bottle had been a landmark for New Jerseyans as they headed down the Garden State Parkway for the shore.

Those closings ushered in the dark ages of beer brewing in New Jersey. Not only had the breweries that thrived in the state for a century closed their doors, but the archaic and confusing alcohol and beverage laws in the state left it behind others in the renaissance of American beer brewing that was just getting started.

Climax breweryA gradual loosening of some of those regulations led to the rebirth of microbrewing in New Jersey. Climax Brewing in Roselle Park became New Jersey’s first modern microbrewery in 1993. One the most successful, Flying Fish in Cherry Hill, started in 1995 as a virtual brewery then opening its doors in 1996 as did River Horse Brewing in Lambertville. Brew pubs finally became legal in New Jersey in 1994 and one year later the Ship Inn Restaurant and Brewery in Milford became the first brew pub in New Jersey.

According to New Jersey Craft Beer there are in 2015 37 operating breweries in the state and 15 brew pubs. Another 22 start ups have a license, permit or physical location and 16 more are planned but haven’t yet gotten to that point. So we’re getting close to the 51 breweries that were in production in 1900.

This entry was posted in History and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

30 Responses to The History of Beer in New Jersey

  1. Beth Niebuhr says:

    Very interesting. German beer, yum! I love it. Prohibition was a real game changer but it’s good that some could come back afterwards. Quite a story. Going from tiny breweries to big and bigger and now micro breweries have arisen far and wide.


  2. GP Cox says:

    I heard there was an Artesian well near the Pabst brewery they used for thier water supply – True or False?


  3. jacquiegum says:

    Wow, what a history! Even though I’ve never had a beer in Hoboken, ever, Makes me wish I had:) I thought the scratch off bikini-clad label was genius! Perhaps a bit before its time! Nice to see the ebb and flow of the tides of time. Little to big and then back again. Really interesting, and a great read.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Erica says:

    People get so excited over beer. I’ve personally never really cared for it. It reminds me of being in college and having my shoes stick to the floor after all the parties from the night before. And I have spent a little time of my life in Hoboken, but I never went to a pub. Very interesting to learn the history if it all.


  5. Ken Dowell says:

    If you don’t like having your shoes stick to the floor, you were wise to stay out of the Hoboken bars.


  6. lenie5860 says:

    Very interesting history of beer. Imagine starting a brewery at the age of 21, like Gottfried Krueger. We actually have a lot of Kruegers living in our community – descendants, you think? I have never heard of the Lenni Lenape but am now going to look them up and see what I can find out about the. Interesting post as always Ken.


  7. The German background of it explains why I enjoyed NJ beer during college road trips there. German beer–thick and hearty–is still my favorite. Near beer? Light beer? What are those? ha ha.


  8. Wow, can you get any more of my interests in one post; history and beer.
    Find someone with the history of pretzels, and I have a party.
    Thanks for sharing this great informative post with us.


  9. What a fascinating history of beer in New Jersey. I had know prior knowledge of anything to do with the brewing history of the state. “Europeans came from places where there was nothing in the beer that equaled the toxicity of the water.” Is this a serious statement? If so, where did they get the water they used to brew their beer?


  10. Edward Reid says:

    I experienced my own beer history in the Midwest, Milwaukee to be exact. I realized even at a young age that the large German community impacted not only the beer, but much of the food in the area. The diversity must be embraced. Enjoy what others bring to your country.


  11. Interesting. It’s the kind of information that I would never find out on my own. Not only because I’m not a beer drinker but also becasue I don’t live in New Jersey.


  12. Interesting story. Thanks for sharing.


  13. Now that I’m a bonafide wine snob, I’ve been branching out a bit into beers. I’m finding I like the darker ones the best. As for three giant steins I drank in Munich as last years Oktoberfest… never again 😉


  14. Andy says:

    I’m intrigued by that Pabst Blue Ribbon ad. Was PBR a better beer in 1911 than it is now? I wouldn’t serve PBR to guests unless they were unwanted guests.

    Do the Irish play a part in your story, Ken? If memory serves, the black gold of Guinness goes back to 1759, not quite 20 years before the start of the American Revolution.


  15. I see “New Jersey ” in the title and I gotta read it! I grew up in Jersey City, many friday nights were spent in Hoboken at the “Clam Broth House”, with a kettle of steamed clams and a pitcher of cold beer, (not me of course, I was a mere child). But I never knew that New Jersey was a Beer capitol. I can think of other types of capitols’s it’s been called, but never beer.


  16. How interesting and informative. I passed through NJ plenty of times between home in NYC and Univ of PA but never knew. =)


  17. Jason @ says:

    It’s amazing how history kind of repeats itself. One time the brewing industry was booming in New Jersey. Then it died out for a while. Now it looks like it’s growing again. If I’m ever in Jersey I would love to tour a few of the breweries.

    Liked by 1 person

  18. Love this post cos I love my beer especially German beer.
    Its on my to do list to tour a brewery. I’m hoping to do that when I visit Berlin next month.
    What a fascinating history of beer in New Jersey.
    Thanks for sharing Ken x


  19. Dawn (Gaertner) Murtagh says:

    It’s 2019 and I am not sure if you will get this but my great great grandfather started the gaertner brewery in 1847? Or later not sure of the year but was open for one year. How can I find out more info on it and why so many didn’t make it. Also is there a way to find his receipt?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Ken Dowell says:

      Not sure how to track down that one. I did just read a book “The United States of Beer” that talks about what happened to all those 19th century breweries. Many of the ones that made it into the 20th century got wiped out by Prohibition.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.