How Teens Won the War Between the Generations

In 1900, nobody used the term teenager. If you were an adolescent boy in Europe, you were likely being prepared for the military. In the U.S., you would be expected to take your part in industry, as in maybe a factory job. And if you were a young girl, most preparation was aimed at marriage.

Seventy-five years later adolescents are now called teenagers. They hang around mostly with each other and set standards among their peers for music, style and behavior. They are, in the words of author Thomas Hine (The Rise and Fall of the American Teenager) “the future in your face.”

Throughout that 75-year period the adult world pretty consistently denounced the outward signs of the emerging teenage world. At the same time, they were forfeiting their influence and authority by screwing up both the peace and the prosperity, problems for which young people bore an inordinate amount of the consequences.

Valentine DanceThe earliest signs of a self-defined teen culture and style were in the 1920’s. Jazz, dance halls and flappers signaled an interest in the here and now and in having fun over and above any concern with preparing for an adulthood that seemed to matter only to the adults in their lives. And with each iteration of often musically-inspired teen culture, whether it be jazz or swing or rock ‘n’ roll, bobby socks, zoot suits or leather jackets, the adult world was there to greet it with scorn, if not outright panic. It has always been the case that, as Hine writes “teenagers bear an inordinate share of the blame for society’s failures.”

Consider these examples:

  • As early as 1898, the British press coined the term “hooligan” in response to the public’s panic over juvenile delinquency.
  • Once they were finished with the fiasco known as Prohibition, the religious right of the 1930’s turned their attention to denouncing movies, a preferred pastime of the young, and called for censorship.
  • In the late 30’s the Catholic bishop of Dubuque denounced swing as “evil” and “communistic.”
  • Meanwhile in Nazi Germany, the SS felt the need to specifically denounce Benny Goodman and George Gershwin.
  • One British commentator explained the rise in rates of venereal disease between 1939 and 1941 as a result of “the jungle rhythms heard by juveniles from morning till bedtime.“
  • And in Los Angeles, in 1944, the city council banned the zoot suit referring to it as a “badge of hoodlumism.”
  • Meanwhile in New York, the education commissioner blamed Frank Sinatra for making adolescents lose control.
  • In the 1950’s the town of Bridgeport, Conn., banned rock ‘n’ roll dances.
  • In 1957 when the Soviet Union launched Sputnik, some Americans actually opined that this space race loss was proof of the link between teen culture and the Communist conspiracy.

A wary eye was cast on music and dancing and virtually any style that arose from the teen ranks. A non-orthodox appearance was associated with delinquency. We still haven’t gotten over that. But the delinquency was more perception than reality, as, for example, with the emergence of the rock ‘n’ roller. The press and the public bemoaned an associated rise in delinquency, but actual crime statistics suggest there was no real escalation.

Viewed from the perspective of the young, the adult world was rapidly losing credibility, not only because of their ridiculous focus on jazz and zoot suits, but because they were seriously making a mess of the world. All those European boys who were being trained for the military as the 20th century started were likely sacrificed in the brutal and senseless Great War.  Jon Savage, author of Teenage, described it this way: ““In this mass war, millions of adolescents would be involved together in the surrender of their youth, if not their life, a generational holocaust that would have unforeseen and long-lasting consequences.” He adds, “The Great War had forever destroyed the automatic obedience that elders had expected from youth.”

That scene would be replayed in the 40’s with the second World War and in America again in the 60’s in Vietnam where “American youth were expected to pay the highest price for this military adventure although no one could give them a good reason why,” according to Grace Palladino in Teenagers: An American History.

Then there were the adults who ran the economy. In 1929 they brought it down, ushering in a decade of hunger and desperation that for teens meant no money, no food and often no home as their families broke apart. Wall Street was to treat us to another economic debacle blow, albeit a lesser one, decades later as they redeployed their resources to back financial instruments built from sub-prime mortgages.

Even in the relatively good times of the 1920’s in America, young people lost considerable respect for the adult world and their laws thanks to Prohibition, a Constitutional amendment that most Americans didn’t want, didn’t respect and routinely violated.

Teenagers at the drive-inWhile this was going on, another important factor in the emergence of teens as teens was their increased separation from adults. As high school became commonplace for most American teens, peers replaced parents as sources of influence. The growth of car ownership offered teens some privacy. And during the Second World War, with large numbers of young men conscripted into Europe and Asia, younger teens and girls entered the work force, drew paychecks, and afterwards were no longer willing to return to a dependent or domestic role.

There’s no better example of the growing disconnect between teens and their parents in the 20th century than on the issue of sex. Teen sex was generally denied and denounced by the adult world. That is when they weren’t ignoring the topic altogether. In the meantime, the average age at which teens lost their virginity dropped with each generation.

By the 1970’s, Paladino writes, “The controversial counterculture of sex, drugs and rock ‘n’ roll suggested the generation gap was now unbridgeable.” She adds “Teenagers in the 1970’s had won the battle for freedom that high school students had been waging since the 1930’s.”

This entry was posted in History, History of Teenagers, Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to How Teens Won the War Between the Generations

  1. Of course, “Footless” ran through my mind reading this post, Ken. Teenagers running amok to music–what could be better? Total enjoy the progression of reading about the impact that teenagers have had/are having on our society.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Great post. I am right now, dealing with two teenagers so I can tell you first-hand that they are a different breed. Some years back, I read a research study that said that in the teenage years, the teen’s brain is actually growing so some of their decisions may not make sense. I do see a difference now with my kids. But back then, I can see why parents banned things like music. I don’t agree with it but I do understand it. Thanks for sharing.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. heraldmarty says:

    Funny, i also thought of Footloose as I reading your post. I suppose it’s a sort of iconic example of that whole era. This is a real eye opener Ken and very enjoyable read.

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Phoenicia says:

    I did not enjoy my teenage years at all. I felt vulnerable, unhappy, confused, unnacepted like a square trying to fit through a round hole.

    There are so many emotions to deal with as a teen and now social media has been thrown into the mix.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. My students used to get a kick out of it when I would point out how they literally weren’t in their right minds because their minds weren’t done growing yet. A fully formed mind cannot make a well-informed decision, and boy do teenagers make some crazy decisions.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. lenie5860 says:

    Ken, I am really enjoying this series because a lot of this was still true when I was a teenager in the late 50’s early 60′. I got a kick out of the zoot suit being banned or the blame attached to Frank Sinatra. Later on it was Elvis who was blamed for our downfall and of course bringing the Beatles to America didn’t help things as far as our parents were concerned. Looking back now though, even with all the changes that were happening to the world around teenagers, it was still very much an innocent time.

    Liked by 2 people

  7. My father had a friend who told him that the worst thing to deal with are teenage girls. Have to admit there is truth to that statement.

    Liked by 1 person

  8. Erica says:

    I had a teacher in school theorize that part of the rebellious teen culture is the result of us no longer having any kind of ritual to help a child transition into adulthood. Lots of tribes have sojourns to welcome a boy to manhood. And the Bar Mitzvah does the same thing (though it isn’t taken seriously in American culture. But classically it was a big deal to mark a very real transition at just 13 years old. Modern teens are just left in limbo. Very interesting post. And now I need to look up the term zoot suit. I’ve heard of it but have no clue what it is.

    Liked by 2 people

  9. Andy says:

    One suspects that there was a certain jealousy in the things that adults said/did about teens way back when: to the extent that adults were willing to develop interests in the first place, they realized on some level that those interests were pretty banal compared to what the teens were doing.

    Is teen culture edgier than adult culture today? Not in my book. Who would you rather listen to, One Direction or the Rolling Stones?


  10. I remember the phrase from my youth “Don’t trust anyone over 35”
    You bring up good points in your post. I also believe there was so much focus put upon teens, and was lowered to adults. This was because the 20th century was the first time teens had deposable income, they became a rich source of revenue for marketing. With this trend toward youth, I think adults felt more like they were loosing control.
    Thanks for sharing this insightful post with us.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. Ken Dowell says:

    When I was in school the phrase was “don’t trust anyone over 30.” I’m probably a little older so I guess they later admitted the 30-35 year olds into the trustworthy category.


  12. Which is why I homeschool. =)


  13. looking back now I enjoyed my teenage years. Then nothing like social media etc.
    Great post Ken and thanks for sharing this insightful post x

    Liked by 1 person

  14. jan says:

    It’s frightening to think that at one time teenagers were considered inexperienced adults! Course now they’re often treated like oversized children! Interesting article – thanks!

    Liked by 1 person

  15. Great post. Had to chuckle at Jan’s comment. So true. We have went from one extreme to the other in how teenagers are treated it seems. Need some middle ground.


  16. My teenage years were interesting. They were fun but I think 18 & 19 were the best years out them. I was still technically a teen, but I was also an adult on my own in college.


  17. Pingback: The Invention of the Teenager | off the leash

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.